Wednesday, September 9, 2009
The Three Golden Oranges
We have been working on prediction and inference in reading this week. Using what you learned, what do you infer will occur if the story continues? Remember the last line of the book is, "No one really knows what happened to Santiago and Tomas, but if I ever find out I will be happy to tell you," so what do you think happens?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
51 comments:
well guess what. I found out. One day when they where out picking corn, two butiful women walked by and they fell in love. They each had three children and evry one lived hapily ever after.
cameron
I think that the guards will forget about them in the dungeon and they will not get food or water and live lonely lives. In that case, they will eventually die and be all bones
scattered all over the cell.
-Greta
I've found out what happened to santiago and Tomas and to tell the truth its pretty interesting. First is santiago, he was sent to a stranded island by the old woman in the middle of the atlantic ocean surrounded by hungry sharks and all he has to eat/drink is oranges. Every orange he eats a woman comes out asking him for water and bread but he never has it. Tomas is currently living on the moon waiting for the next space ship to come and save him and he eats moon oranges accept every orange he eats an alien comes out asking him for moon water and moon bread, but he can never find it. Just to tell you matias is living at home with his wife growing golden oranges and successfully selling them to people who were in the same situation as him and his brothers. And they lived happily ever after, well at least matias did.
Erik
I think that the two older brothers got sent back to the dungeon.I'm predicting that because the first time they had tried to take the oranges/girls the brothers got sent straight to the dungeon.I also think Matias will go look for the brothers and persuade the wizard to give him his brothers back
Jack
I think Tomas and Santiago got rescued by their brother Matias and they did get wives. It's just they came from different golden oranges and for Tomas he gets a very poor and ugly wife and for Santiago he gets the most homely wife in Spain.On top of that they will be greedy.
Elizabeth
I think Santiago and Tomas spent all their lives captured together at the castle. Every day they think about how their lives might have been different if they weren't selfish and greedy.
pilar
This is what I think happens to Santiago and Tomas. I think they both will try to improve, Santiago in looks, Tomas in wealth, in vain attempts to woo their almost-wives back to them. But of course they don't succeed, and despite trying to cover up their tracks, the Witch will find them, and (this one's a little off the deep end) make them share the fate of what the beautiful sisters used to live like, thus turning them into oranges.
Desi :} =[
I infer that Santiago will have to find a new home of some kind. I think the same for Tomas. I then think that they will be turned into frogs or something else in their sleep. Matais will probably find them and mistake them for real frogs and then find something to do with them.
Brendan
I think that Santiago and Tamas will go back to the old woman and ask for a second chance . The old woman will refuse , and , being as dumb as they are , they will threaten to harm her with weapons . She still refuses to give them another chance . They harm her and she repeats her words
" You did not follow my instructions , woe to you ." And , in whirl of dust , they where whisked back to the castle , but this time , not as humans , but as two more golden oranges .
I think that tomas and Santiago got turned into oranges and two woman are looking for husbands. The same thing happens to what happened to the three brothers.I think that matias is going to try and look for his brothers but doesn't find them. =] =}=]=} shania
I think that Santiago and Tomas went back to the old lady who told them how to get wives. They were angry with her and started to yell at her about the wives they received. They said, "We did not get the wives we wanted!" And the old lady said, "Yes you did, i gave you exactly the wives for which you asked!" They kept yelling that they wanted wives that were beautiful and rich and would be there wives forever. The old lady got really angry and yelled that she gave them exactly what they asked for; wives that were beautiful and rich. They were too mean and greedy and that was the reason they lost their wives. So the old lady cursed them and she awoke the sea goddess who rose up and entrapped them in a sea bubble cave for a hundred years or until they could learn to love others unsselfishly. Mathias and his wife loved eachother and lived happily ever after with lots of children.
Manna
As far I have read, these people have a pretty wide spread imagination. Well, think of this. If Matias ever gives his elder brothers a thought, among his splendor and his dream wife, maybe he will finally be altered to his senses.He will be driven mad by a dream that painfully movies his brothers being tourtured by the wizard that imprisoned his beloved wife.His wife though, feels she over looked Matias, and refuses to belive him.When he goes to the "elder" old-lady, she is anoyed because she lived happily and knew that his brothers were on there own island living in the lap of luxury. So she turened the Matias who was ringing his hands in such a crazy way, into a pile of stones.
Do you want to know what happened to Santiago and Tomas? Well then you've come to the right place. So Santiago eventuly got tired of looking for a wife and he eventually bougt a hut in the middle of a swamp very far away. He had nobody to talk to, nothing to do, and even worse, NO WIFE!!! But the worst thing of all, is that all he could eat was GRASS!! As for Tomas, well he got a job as a wood cutter at the dungeon. He got paid very poorly and got very little food. So there's not much else to tell, accept that Matias has one kid, but other than that.... well we'll just wait and see.
Brandon
I think they are gonna think about they're selfish lives, then eventually die!
Happy huh!?
Nick :)
I think they will have a miserable time in the dungeon, and then get out of trouble. Then they go to a kingdom full of rats and ask the wisest rat the secret to happiness. He will say family, and they will say they don't have one. They will skulk away and see beutiful women walk by, and they will all live happily, but not to happy, except Mateo. Bye.
Santiago and Tomas will spend the rest of their lives punished by the old woman.Each time the brothers plant oranges, the most beautiful lady walks by.When either boy asks them for their hand in marriage, they say no very rudely..Each lady is more beautiful as the next.The boys plant oranges until they die.The oranges never ripen,except three on each tree.
Carson
I think that Santiago and Tomas grow old.They see their wives of their dreams with other men.One day Matias visits them and shows them his nice family.Santiago and Tomas both think they should of followed the wise ladys instructions.So they lived sad miserable lives imprisoned in jail.
Santiana(: :)
I think that Santiago and Tomas are going to stay in prison for eterity and never age,making them misrible for the rest of thier lives (don't forget THIER LIVES NEVER END!!!!!!!!!!!).As for Matias and Blanca Flor,well they enjoyed every second of thier lives together ever since they got married.They enjoyed growing,picking,peeling,and selling oranges from thier orchards.Then they lived happily ever after (at least Matias did).
P.S. Did I spell Blanca Flor right?
Jonas
Really, nick you actually think there going to go off to some random place thinking of there selfish lives and die? and you think thats a happy ending!!!!!!!?
I do to exept they go to the moon and a stranded island insteaad, think its sort of funny and is possible because they are selfish and where else would they go.
Erik
Alternate Conclusion to The Three Golden Oranges
Matias and Blancaflor have married. Matias concedes to search for his elder brothers, and presages Blancaflor that the voyage is too perilous for her. He searches the areas around the castle and dungeon, he scrutinizes the orange grove, and journeys back to the cliff where the elder old lady is. He decides to search the orange grove once more, for he has a suspicion that his brothers are somehow trapped there. He plucks two golden oranges from a branch and, before he takes a bite of the first orange, Santiago and his spouse appear out of the orange. Santiago demanded Matias to force him back in, and Matias did so. Matias began to take a bite from the other orange, however, as he starts to peel it, Tomas and his new wife appear out of the orange. Tomas remarks that he wants to avoid further imprisonment in the dungeon, and asks Matias to let him back into the the orange, and Matias did so. Matias returned to his abode and told Blancaflor of the stunning news. It is unknown what happened to Santiago and Tomas after their concealed discovery.
Alternate Conclusion #2 by Dean
Response to Comment
I thought that Zoe's prediction/inference was great - I loved the creativity and mine was sort of the same. The comment that I posted was that Santiago and Tomas were actually trapped in the oranges.
Love the creativity and use of prior knowledge in the book.
Dean - Comment Response
I agree with Jack,Pilar and Atticus because I think Santiago and Tomas will try to get the oranges again and the guards are going to see them and put them in the dungeon and forget about them
-Greta
Nick,if they die how can they be happy?I would like a more LOGICAL responce.PLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEASE!!!!!!
By the way,cam,you mispelled every it's not spelled evry.
Oh,and Dean I LOOOOVE your responce it is soooo creative.
I like yours too,Erik.
Jonas
I agree with jack because it is logical and that is what I would have said if I woudent have come up with what I did.
cameron
I think Desi's coment is creative and very true , with the choices Santiago and Tomas I'm not surprised that they tried to become better and there atempt
failed .
pilar-coment
Desi yours is great!!That is totally what Santiago and Tomas would do!I loved it!The punishment is perfect for them.I loved it!!!!!
-Carson
I think that Santiago will go insane and ask the gaurds to feed him oranges. But every time Santiago slices one open a women appears and asks him for bread and water.Tomas was not so lucky, every time he gets an orange it turns into a fire breathing dragon that eats pigs.Tomas died because of toxic butt poising, and all the guards got a wife because Santiago ate so many oranges that his skin became orange and his hair became green.The gaurds called Santiago "oompa loompa".Soon the castle was overrun by babies.
Taylor
I kind of had the same idea as Desi. True , as she said , it was a little off the deep end , but it makes sense . They where charged with a terrible fate . To become oranges .
Erik, I think yours is absolutely just plain AWESOME. It has great suffering for both brothers for what they need to do to reform their thoughts. They would certainly be devastated to be in either situation. Although, Nick, I think you went a bit over the top. It was amusing, but I think you could make it longer and better by adding detail like some other kids did. Jack, I think yours is great, but I think you should get into a bit of detail. Manna, I think yours has great usage of dialogue. In other words, I think it was great! Zoe, I like how yours had a distinctly mysterious expression when I read it. Dean, I simply loved your word choice and plot. Taylor, I think yours is complete and total INSANITY. That is very good. I like it.
Brendan
I think Elizebath's is most likely to happen. Why? They're greedy people.
I think that the two older brothers will be brought to the witch.Then for the witch/elder's own pleasure she will make them do her work or any other labor she has till they learn to not be greedy or selfish. CORI
I agree with Jack, Pilar, Atticus, and Greta, I think that they will get out of prison, try for the oranges, or be tortured, like in Erik's ending.
Oscar
I thought that carson's comment was really cool. I thought it really made sense and it felt like the exact thing the auother could have put in the book. CORI
I think that all the brothers will get married,and... I think that all the brothers will get married,and have one kid,so each of the brothers will be in a family of 3. Then their kids will go to the old woman and ask for beautiful wives. And then the going to the old lady thing and going to prison thing will happen for 3 generations,and a new thing would happen for 4. Skylar
I agree with Greta because I think that the guards will forget about tomas and santiago and eventully die. -shania
I think Greta's thought was great. because in prison,you don't get realesed a few minuts later.the gaurds could have had anohther baddie at the gates and then fogot about the brothers. greta did a good job.
SKYLAR
I agree with Shania. The wise lady said "woo on you if you don't follow my instructions."
SANTIAN-comment on Shania's
Taylor-
You response really didn't make sense, and what the heck is toxic butt poisoning???? It's not listed in any of the medical books I have read.
Anyway, even though it was pretty much the most unlikely thing to happen, I thought it had a real comedic taste.
-Dean
I also have to agree with Erik's and Jonas's responses to Nick's comment - how can one be happy when they come to a demise? I know that the response was facetious, but still....
Dean Buelter, M.D.
I agree wth Desi because she is not being soft on Tomas and Santiago. They get what they deserve for being selfish and greedy. That's why my ending was so mean. Manna
No afense but I do'nt like some comments that are unfair. Well they're unfair that they do'nt get but Erik,Dean,and Jonas I think that that Jonas is right. Brendon I really liked your story. Manna
I agree with both Jonas and Taylor they could both happen COULD,not very likely but still possible.
Jack
I think Jonas's idea is extremely likely. I also think it's very logical. The wizard could have cast a spell on the older brothers and caused eternal misery. Matias probably did get eternal romance and happiness , all the makes for a great (fairytale!) life.
Elizabeth
Desi! That is auwsume!You are sooooooooooo creative!I think you were being logical,imaginative and funny.Plus,your ending was ominus in a really my-mind way and it kept me smiling. Zoe,you were also real creative. Brynn~Brynn Morgan Orloff Gauthier
I agree with Zoe's coment on the The Three Golden Oranges. As she says in her coment "as dumb as they are, they threaten to harm her with weapoms. " shows with how dumb the brothers may eventually turn out to be in her point of view. I agree with this coment as it is very fit to the story as an alternate enbing.
Brandon
They leave the county searching for other golden oranges in other countrys until they finally found some and when their wives apeared they learned that they were not what they wanted and there wives were rich and snobby making the men wait on their hands and feet
Alastair
Nick,
If they live selfish lives then how can they be happy
Alastair
Post a Comment