Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Perspective on Columbus

We have been studying different perspectives on history. What is your opinion on Columbus now? Is he a good guy or a bad guy? This must be at least five sentences. In addition, I will be grading this response so do your best work!

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think, based on reading "Encounter," that Columbus was a mixture of good and bad. On the bad side, I think that it is inequitable that he got to claim the Native American's land, thus as a ramifaction the Native American population shrunk to a minimal amount and they are now poverty stricken. On the good side, however, Columbus DID set foot on America and DID bring back wealth to Europe, which needed it badly at that time. Then again, this falls under the bad category. Once again: was Columbus good or bad? My answer is a mixture of both.

Dean




P.S. I forgot to put my name on my last comment, so I did this one. My apologies.

Anonymous said...

My opinion on Columbus is not very good. I picture him as a bad guy. He was unfair to the Natives by selling them as slaves. He also took their gold jewelry and valuables for the king and queen of Spain. As he tricked them into becoming slaves they made lots of trades. This is why I think Columbus is a bad guy.

-GRETA

Anonymous said...

I think Columbus was definitely not a good person.
He may have opened up many countries to Europe, but then again, those cultures live on. Those people have respectable homes, they don't live in trailers or in the worst land possible. Because of Columbus, the Spanish came into America and destroyed the Native American's lives, and made them work the land. Columbus was famous for bringing countries together, but in the process, he forgot that Native Americans were human beings. Exploration was inevitable, but it was Columbus's choice to bring slaves back to Spain and start the slave trade that would leave a mark on history for many years.
Desi

Anonymous said...

Columbus seemed like he was good at first in the book.Then the tables turned.Columbus took some of the Natives and sold them as slaves.He might be nice in one book and may not be the best in another book.I think Columbus is hard to decide on between good and bad.I am inbetween.

SANTIANA

Anonymous said...

I don't think chrisopher is a bad person, but he's not nessesaraly the best person of all time eihther
you know. He was belived to be the first person to set foot on american soil. Well, as everyone knows, the first recorded person was Leif Eriksson.


Nick

Anonymous said...

I think he is bolth a good guy and bad guy. he is a bad guy because He probobly just captured the slaves just for fun. evryone makes mistakes in life and he did exactly that. he is a good guy because he wanted to help spain with there knowlege. overall I think he was more good guy than bad guy.

cameron

Anonymous said...

I thing Columbus could be good or bad. Of course I want gold, who wouldn't?! I can see why Columbus wants the Native Americans gold, but if he thinks capturing and killing are the only way to get any, he is not very worthy of his mind. Before you read the book 'Encounters', you think "Wow, Columbus dicovered America, and it wasn't even on purpose! How cool.". After you read the book, you think "Scince when would Columbus do such a thing".

Brandon

Anonymous said...

Columbus had different scales of his personal action. Some were 10's. Others... were more of a mix of ones and twos. Stealing people off their their native land and leaving the ones left behind into little lean-to's was the most definite one. On the good side, he taught Europe many new customs and showed them new customs,such as chocolate and fine tobaccos, which they have now mastered. He's an unexplainable mix of the two.

Elizabeth

P.S
I am NOT saying smoking or chewing tobacco is good for you.Europeans are just really good at it.

Anonymous said...

I think it really depends on who you are. For example, if you were a native american, you might find him the antagonist, or the bad guy, but as a spaniard in that time, you might regard him as the protagonist, or the hero. Personally, I can't decide whether he is either. I mean, yeah, he discovered America and survived, but he gave made the native americans the butt of the stick. Honestly, I think it is a huge debate in my mind, but also, for some it could be easy. That is my opinion.
Brendan

Anonymous said...

I think that columbus was a good guy. He was only doing things because his advisors who paid for the trip asked him to. Plus it wasn't his fault that the Tano got killed and sold as slaves. It was mostly new settlers who took them as slaves. He did bring back some of the Tano. But they where only examples\references to people who might want to live in the new land. He didn't start slave trade either, did he. he was also the first to set foot present day America too, wasn't he?
In conclution I think he was goood. Don't forget that book is fictional.




Jonas
P.S. earase my first one. Thanks!

Anonymous said...

I picture Columbus as a bad person and not kind. He did not explore to find discoveries but he did everything for gold. The Native American's were very welcoming to Columbus and he took them and sold them as slaves. He viewed the Native Americans as inferior beings and therefore treated them very poorly. He did not help really with the work that was being done, but just ordered people around. He was a very selfish and uncaring person and that is why I would consider him to be bad.
Manna

Anonymous said...

I don't think that Columbus is a bad person but he isn't the best person I ever imagined. He is bad because took the Native American's land. A good thing Columbus did is get gold for Europe. He also was the first one to discover America. This why he is just an ok person.
Carl

Anonymous said...

I'm leaning torwards a bad guy for Columbus. Because all he cared about was money . He didn't care about the indian's culture or what they were doing for him .He just wanted there gold and to sell them as slaves.Sure he did all this for Spain, but he did treat the Indians badly and wiped out most of the Native Americans population . So I think Columbus is a bad guy.Because of what he did to the Native American's .

Pilar

Zoe said...

I don't think he was a very good person overall . He sold Native Americans as slaves . Sure, he was trying to help Spain , but he did bad things in the process . If you are going to do something for a good cause , but have to destroy something just as good to have it happen , why do it at all ? But ,as Dean said , Columbus did bring riches to Spain . Plus , how would history have changed if he didn't do what he did ? We wouldn't be here . I'm not saying what he did was a good thing , I am switching things up .

Brynn said...

Based on the reading "Encounter", I think Columbus changed the course of history. But not all in a good way. Sure, he did become the first European to set foot on American soil, but he changed the Natives' lifestyle too. He was willing to be friendly, as long as he got their gold. He pretty much brought about slavery. Chris dedicated this trip for the better of Europe, but what about the better of the Native population? I think this would fall under the bad catergory because of his lack of awareness. Christopher Columbus obviously made mistakes.

Anonymous said...

I think that after reading "Encounter",my thoughts changed about Columbus.I say this baecause in the book it said that he took the Natives as slaves.But when he did it he didn't bribe them or anything,they just came beacause they thought that they where nice.They where honered geasts,and Columbus took them for grantige.These are my feelings about Columbus,and when you raed this book mabby your thoughts about Columbus will change too.Isaac

BRYNN said...

I have realized, while reading that, that everybody has very diffrent perspectives on the way Columbus worked. I like Deans for his great information on why he thinks that.

Anonymous said...

I think that Columbus is okay but, he did make some very bad mistakes. He did take the Native Americans as slaves and grab some of their gold. He also brought lots of new things to America and more things back to Europe. Columbus' choices make modern Natives living on the worst land in America. Even when Columbus was alive, the natives were treated badly. He is good and bad in my opinion.

-Carson

atticus said...

I think that Columbus was a bad guy with many good tendencies. He was nice to the tana, then ambition was his own master. But everyone is saying he's bad because of the slaves and such. Big deal! It was 1400s. They didn't have the bill of rights!!

Anonymous said...

I think after reading "Encounter"that Columbus made the rong choice of taking the Native Americans.But I think that coumbus was also doing what most people did,taking slaves.Columbus then did not understand what slavery would become. CORI

Anonymous said...

I think that its not right to sell slaves, or lie, but all of that made today today. But how can we tell if different choices could have made a better future? Or a worse? So I thionk that he is a mix, for that is the closest to indecision.

Ocsar

Anonymous said...

My opinion on Columbus now is that he is a bad guy and a good guy because he did help out his country (Spain)but he took gold,land and the people from the Tanio tribe.So I don't know if he's a good guy or a bad guy.As other people said they're in between but I think he's more bad guy. Shania

Anonymous said...

Columbus good or bad??? I have to say a mixture of both.On the bad side,he murdered the indians numbers from 200% to 25% than took over the land that was the indians "property" and took slaves from peaceful people doing no harm.On the good side,he did bring wealth and "goodies" from the "new world" that was needed to bring spain back to it's full power and the slaves wern't his fault.They were just examples to prove he found a new land.Columbus good or bad:It has to be a mixture of both. TAYLOR/ sparky

Anonymous said...

I agree with Dean.He was bad because he took gold and people as slaves from the Taino.But he was good because he did all that for his country.Therefore I think Columbus is good and bad.

Jack

Anonymous said...

Back then I think he wood probably be known as a good guy,this is because doing what he did, stealing the land from the indians was like buying groceries from a store which back then was'nt anything wrong.although it was'nt bad back then today it is one of the worst things you could do. Stealing the indians land that they found and taking them as slaves is destroying there lives, which which is definitely bad so I would say he's somewhere around the middle because it was nothing back then but now it would be known as destroying everything they had and ruining there lives.



Erik