Today we finished watching, "Murder on the Orient Express," for our murder mystery unit. The ending of this movie is one of the greatest of all time. Yet, it raises a moral question. Is murder ever justified?
19 comments:
Anonymous
said...
Murder is never justified, because even if the murderer was executed the excuetion would count as murder. So murder can be chan or murder just isn't fully justified. So murder is never justified.
On any account, murder is never justified whatsoever. I could see WHY the murderers got off the hook in the movie, because it was a child who was killed. Despite this, two wrongs do not make a right, and violence is never the solution to anything.
I think murder can be justified it it was for self defense or revenge. I think that because it matters on the case and what had happened for the murder to happen. Like in our murder mystery plays everyone has a reason to kill the person who dies, that is the same within Murder on the Orient Express. It also depends on what the murderer did to get murdered. Someone might have killed them for no reason but they should have a reason.Murder can be justified.
The question was if it was ever justified and yes, I believe it is. People are sentenced to death and to life in prison. Sometimes (Murder on the Orient Express), murder is not justified. Ratchet or Caseti got off the hook in trial, but not on the train. Of course, murder was justified to those people, but not to Caseti/Ratchet (or Daisy Armstrong). I agree that not always murder is justified, but most of the time, it is pretty equal. ~Carson
I really think that at times, it is. Murder is like a swing made of duct tape. In the beginning, it works, like when someone kills a bunch of kids, they are murdered back for there bad deed.In the end with the duct tape coming apart, this happens :this time is when that person killls , lets say, kids and gets away with it. That really isn't fair. In this context, sometimes murder is OK. It is not always right, such as a maniac going on homicide in an orphanage. I think it is OK if someone kills someone who went on homicide at an orphanage.
I think that some murders are justified but it really depends. In Murder On The Orient Express I think the murder is justified because Casseti murdered Daisy Armstrong which then caused other people to die. I also think the murder was justified in And Then There Were None because they all committed a crime and it was just getting back at them for what they did to other people. In real life it depends because if a child or an adult was murdered. It also depends if there is other deaths because of the murder or if money is involved. So I think the murder was justified in Murder On The Orient Express and And Then There Were None, but in real life it depends on the person who was murdered and other things that were involved.
Murder is justified in some cases but not in others. For instance, in the movie, everybody stabbed Ratchett with the same motive. Ratchett killed several people and this very much hurt the people, so they killed him. I'll be honest, I don't think any of the people on the train should hhave gotten in trouble, for hurting Ratchett, becaue if he hadn't killed anybody in the first place, nothing would have happened.
I think that it depends whether murder is justified or not. As in this case it was a murderer killing a murderer and I think that if Cassetti had gone to court he would have been sentenced to death anyway. I think that since he killed a child and indirectly four other people this particular murder was justified because, as Jonas said, "An adult can never recover from the death of a child, particularly THEIR child." Other than this very special case however, I believe that murder is not justified.
In some cases yes. Murder is justified. It is only justified when the person that is murdered has murderd someone important or a baby/child in Ratchett's case. I think murder should only be justified if the victim is a murderer.
I think that murder is sometimes justified. I think in Murder on the Orient Express murder is justified. If Ratchett hadn't murdered anybody especially a kid nothing would have happened. Also, he caused others to die from grief.
Ha! Dean your response sounded like my mom, "violence is never the solution to anything! Two wroungs don't make a right." But you are correct. I think that murder isn't justified. It can't ever be really justified because the an who would kill the murder would kill in rage. The other no matter who he or she murdered it would be self and own violence. And that can't be matched in any way. It is just too cruel and vicious.
Whether a murder is justified depends solely on the sympathetic values of those giving their point of view. For example, in Cassetti's case, the murder of his person was pardoned because of his relationships to the murder of the Armstrongs. In And Then There Were None, the murders were pardoned because A, all the victims had killed another person, and B, because Wargrave killed himself afterwards, leaving no way to get back at him. As I said, the justification of a murder depends on the sympathetic qualities of those giving their opinion. In addition to this, circumstances must be taken into account. For example, When a child is murdered, the chance of the pardon of the murder of whosoever guilty of the murder is much more likely than an old man's murder's revenge.The human brain is a complicated subject. One usually explains their decisions with their "conscience," but actually, no such thing exists. It is the simple mind deciding from prior knowledge and how humane they are. Essentially, it really depends if murder is justified or not.
Murder is never justified. Never. Even if the murderer killed twenty people and someone else kills him it would edventualy start a chain reaction which would cause everyone to kill each other except the last person standing. So that long, run on sentence concludes that MURDER IS NEVER JUSTIFIED!
I agree with the others who have posted, murder can never be justified. The murderer is punished diffrently according to what he or she did. One really good example is when somone murderes a child and when somone murderes a adult, each case is treated diffrently and the person who murdered the child will probaly recive the worst punishment. The crime may also affect if murder is ever justified. I think that whatever case is fully solved, murder can still not become justified.
The truth is, murder is never justified. Judges sentencing someone to death is justified, but taking the matter into your own hands is not. I agree, Ratchett (Cassetti) would be the most horrible of men, and does not deserve to live to see another moment of daylight, but he should not have been murdered. He should have been sentenced to death. Violence itself is wrong, but MURDER? The people on the train should have turned him in to the police. Then he could have been dealt with in a civilized way. I agree with Dean, two wrongs do not make a right. I also agree with the fact that I do know why they got let off. They should not have killed, but turned him in. This is why murder is not justified.
I think murder is never justified. Usually, in movies it is justified, such as Murder on the Orient Express. But I think if a person murdered a few other people, the murderer should not be killed. They should just be put in prison for the rest of their life.
Since I was not here I don't know the ending, but I can tell you that murder is not always justified but it also can be solved. I agree a lot with Shaina because murder can be revenge or defense. I think a lot of the time that murder is justified because of the reason for murder.
I feel the case of murder is only justified when a person has deserved it, and hurt much humanity before him, and does not feel the guilt one should feel when he has killed numerous people before himself. As the great Agatha Christie herself stated, “Too much mercy... often resulted in further crimes which were fatal to innocent victims who need not have been victims if justice had been put first and mercy second.”
I grew up in a suburb of Chicago and attended the University of Missouri at Columbia for my undergrad. I have a Masters in Elementary Education from Regis.
I come from a family with four kids. My sister is a teacher in Chicago. One of my brothers lives here and the other one lives in Chicago. I moved here because my husband loved Colorado and I loved him. As it turns out,I love Colorado as well.
19 comments:
Murder is never justified, because even if the murderer was executed the excuetion would count as murder. So murder can be chan or murder just isn't fully justified. So murder is never justified.
MANNA
On any account, murder is never justified whatsoever. I could see WHY the murderers got off the hook in the movie, because it was a child who was killed. Despite this, two wrongs do not make a right, and violence is never the solution to anything.
I think murder can be justified it it was for self defense or revenge. I think that because it matters on the case and what had happened for the murder to happen. Like in our murder mystery plays everyone has a reason to kill the person who dies, that is the same within Murder on the Orient Express. It also depends on what the murderer did to get murdered. Someone might have killed them for no reason but they should have a reason.Murder can be justified.
The question was if it was ever justified and yes, I believe it is. People are sentenced to death and to life in prison. Sometimes (Murder on the Orient Express), murder is not justified. Ratchet or Caseti got off the hook in trial, but not on the train. Of course, murder was justified to those people, but not to Caseti/Ratchet (or Daisy Armstrong). I agree that not always murder is justified, but most of the time, it is pretty equal.
~Carson
I really think that at times, it is. Murder is like a swing made of duct tape. In the beginning, it works, like when someone kills a bunch of kids, they are murdered back for there bad deed.In the end with the duct tape coming apart, this happens :this time is when that person killls , lets say, kids and gets away with it. That really isn't fair. In this context, sometimes murder is OK. It is not always right, such as a maniac going on homicide in an orphanage. I think it is OK if someone kills someone who went on homicide at an orphanage.
I think that some murders are justified but it really depends. In Murder On The Orient Express I think the murder is justified because Casseti murdered Daisy Armstrong which then caused other people to die. I also think the murder was justified in And Then There Were None because they all committed a crime and it was just getting back at them for what they did to other people. In real life it depends because if a child or an adult was murdered. It also depends if there is other deaths because of the murder or if money is involved. So I think the murder was justified in Murder On The Orient Express and And Then There Were None, but in real life it depends on the person who was murdered and other things that were involved.
Pilar
Murder is justified in some cases but not in others. For instance, in the movie, everybody stabbed Ratchett with the same motive. Ratchett killed several people and this very much hurt the people, so they killed him. I'll be honest, I don't think any of the people on the train should hhave gotten in trouble, for hurting Ratchett, becaue if he hadn't killed anybody in the first place, nothing would have happened.
-Brandon/ROCKER
I think that it depends whether murder is justified or not. As in this case it was a murderer killing a murderer and I think that if Cassetti had gone to court he would have been sentenced to death anyway. I think that since he killed a child and indirectly four other people this particular murder was justified because, as Jonas said, "An adult can never recover from the death of a child, particularly THEIR child." Other than this very special case however, I believe that murder is not justified.
In some cases yes. Murder is justified. It is only justified when the person that is murdered has murderd someone important or a baby/child in Ratchett's case. I think murder should only be justified if the victim is a murderer.
~~~SANTI~~~~
I think that murder is sometimes justified. I think in Murder on the Orient Express murder is justified. If Ratchett hadn't murdered anybody especially a kid nothing would have happened. Also, he caused others to die from grief.
Jack
I think murders are always justified. If you murder someone you will surly go to H-E-double hockey sticks. The murder will be justified there.
Ha! Dean your response sounded like my mom, "violence is never the solution to anything! Two wroungs don't make a right." But you are correct. I think that murder isn't justified. It can't ever be really justified because the an who would kill the murder would kill in rage. The other no matter who he or she murdered it would be self and own violence. And that can't be matched in any way. It is just too cruel and vicious.
Whether a murder is justified depends solely on the sympathetic values of those giving their point of view. For example, in Cassetti's case, the murder of his person was pardoned because of his relationships to the murder of the Armstrongs. In And Then There Were None, the murders were pardoned because A, all the victims had killed another person, and B, because Wargrave killed himself afterwards, leaving no way to get back at him. As I said, the justification of a murder depends on the sympathetic qualities of those giving their opinion. In addition to this, circumstances must be taken into account. For example, When a child is murdered, the chance of the pardon of the murder of whosoever guilty of the murder is much more likely than an old man's murder's revenge.The human brain is a complicated subject. One usually explains their decisions with their "conscience," but actually, no such thing exists. It is the simple mind deciding from prior knowledge and how humane they are. Essentially, it really depends if murder is justified or not.
Brendan
Murder is never justified. Never. Even if the murderer killed twenty people and someone else kills him it would edventualy start a chain reaction which would cause everyone to kill each other except the last person standing. So that long, run on sentence concludes that MURDER IS NEVER JUSTIFIED!
I agree with the others who have posted, murder can never be justified. The murderer is punished diffrently according to what he or she did. One really good example is when somone murderes a child and when somone murderes a adult, each case is treated diffrently and the person who murdered the child will probaly recive the worst punishment. The crime may also affect if murder is ever justified. I think that whatever case is fully solved, murder can still not become justified.
~CORI~
The truth is, murder is never justified. Judges sentencing someone to death is justified, but taking the matter into your own hands is not. I agree, Ratchett (Cassetti) would be the most horrible of men, and does not deserve to live to see another moment of daylight, but he should not have been murdered. He should have been sentenced to death. Violence itself is wrong, but MURDER? The people on the train should have turned him in to the police. Then he could have been dealt with in a civilized way. I agree with Dean, two wrongs do not make a right. I also agree with the fact that I do know why they got let off. They should not have killed, but turned him in. This is why murder is not justified.
I think murder is never justified. Usually, in movies it is justified, such as Murder on the Orient Express. But I think if a person murdered a few other people, the murderer should not be killed. They should just be put in prison for the rest of their life.
$pazzler/skylar
Since I was not here I don't know the ending, but I can tell you that murder is not always justified but it also can be solved. I agree a lot with Shaina because murder can be revenge or defense. I think a lot of the time that murder is justified because of the reason for murder.
- Greta
I feel the case of murder is only justified when a person has deserved it, and hurt much humanity before him, and does not feel the guilt one should feel when he has killed numerous people before himself. As the great Agatha Christie herself stated, “Too much mercy... often resulted in further crimes which were fatal to innocent victims who need not have been victims if justice had been put first and mercy second.”
Post a Comment